“My and His” or “Mine and His” – Which Is Correct?

Marcus Froland

Have you ever wondered about the correct usage of possessive pronouns in English and whether “my and his” or “mine and his” are grammatically accurate? You are not alone! Possessive pronouns and their proper placements in sentences can often be confusing, leading to unintentional mistakes in written and spoken English.

In this article, we will dive into the English grammar rules surrounding possessive structures, including the differentiation between “my and his” and “mine and his.” We will provide a clear understanding of the correct grammatical usage of possessive pronouns and help you avoid common pitfalls.

Understanding Possessive Pronouns in Grammar

Possessive pronouns in English language grammar play a crucial role in demonstrating ownership and are widely used to replace nouns, preventing unnecessary repetition. To maintain clarity and avoid ambiguity, it is important to understand the proper placement of singular and plural possessive pronouns in sentences. These pronouns should align with the nouns they replace in terms of number (singular or plural) and gender.

Let’s take a closer look at the common possessive pronouns in English:

  1. First person singular: my/mine
  2. First person plural: our/ours
  3. Second person singular and plural: your/yours
  4. Third person singular masculine: his
  5. Third person singular feminine: her/hers
  6. Third person singular neutral: its
  7. Third person plural: their/theirs

Note: Some possessive pronouns, like his and its, remain the same whether they come before or after the noun they modify.

In this room, you’ll find her books and his paintings.

The blue cup is yours, and the red one is mine.

Pronoun agreement is another essential aspect of using possessive pronouns correctly. The pronouns must match the nouns they are replacing regarding their number (singular or plural) and gender. For example:

Incorrect: Each student must bring their own lunch.

Correct: Each student must bring his or her own lunch.

Incorrect: Neither Emily nor Sarah has finished their assignment.

Correct: Neither Emily nor Sarah has finished her assignment.

To further illustrate the importance of possessive pronouns and pronoun agreement, let’s examine the following table:

Possessive Pronoun Correct Application Incorrect Application
his John left his wallet on the desk. Jane lost his wallet in the park.
her Kim tied her shoelaces. Mark couldn’t find her car keys.
their The cat hurt its paw. The cats licked its fur.

By mastering the use of possessive pronouns and ensuring proper pronoun agreement in English language grammar, you can create well-written and grammatically accurate sentences that are easy to understand and free from ambiguity.

The Mistake of “My and His” Explained

In English grammar, word order is a pivotal rule, particularly in possessive structures. Ordering pronouns incorrectly can lead to confusion and incorrect grammatical constructions. The personal pronoun (“my” or “mine”) must always come last in a list of pronouns, to form structures such as “his and my” or “his and mine”.

Why Word Order is Crucial in Possessive Structures

Word order is essential in possessive structures, as it ensures that sentences convey the intended meaning and follow established grammatical rules. Having a proper pronoun placement helps in maintaining clarity and reducing ambiguity. Placing the first-person possessive pronouns (“my” or “mine”) after other pronouns or names, results in structurally sound expressions like “her and my assignment” or “John’s and mine vacation”.

Correct Usage of Personal Pronouns with Examples

Correct usage of personal pronouns is seen in expressions like “his and my idea” or “the bed is his and mine,” which abide by grammatical standards. A useful trick to ensure grammatical correctness is to remove “his and” or other additional pronouns from the sentence. If the remaining structure is correct, such as “This is my house,” then the pronoun is appropriately utilized.

Incorrect: “My and his dog is playing outside.”
Correct: “His and my dog is playing outside.”

Incorrect: “The laptop is my and his.”
Correct: “The laptop is his and mine.”

Following the correct possessive examples and understanding pronoun placement allows for the creation of grammatically sound sentences and eliminates confusion.

  1. Incorrect: Sarah and my presentation went well.
  2. Correct: Sarah’s and my presentation went well.
  • Incorrect: That is Jim and your desk.
  • Correct: That is Jim’s and your desk.
Incorrect Correct
My and her apartment Her and my apartment
The car is mine and his The car is his and mine
Between you and mines Between yours and mine

“His and My” vs. “His and Mine” – Correct Applications

Understanding the distinction between “his and my” and “his and mine” is crucial to ensure grammatical accuracy in shared possession. This differentiation hinges on the positioning of these possessive pronouns relative to the noun they modify.

“His and my” is used before a noun to establish a shared connection with the referenced object or idea. On the other hand, “his and mine” is employed following the noun to indicate joint ownership without repeating the noun. To demonstrate the proper application of each possessive combination, consider the following examples:

His and my anniversary is coming up.
The dog is his and mine.

As seen in these examples, “his and my” precedes a noun (‘anniversary’) while “his and mine” follows the noun (‘dog’) to signify joint ownership.

  1. Applications of “His and My”
  • His and my task was to redesign the website.
  • The proposal is his and my responsibility.
  • Applications of “His and Mine”
  • The apartment is his and mine.
  • That idea is definitely his and mine.

Consistently adhering to the possessive pronoun order and correct pronoun applications in shared possession grammar is crucial to maintain clarity and accuracy in your writing. By doing so, you can avoid common mistakes and ensure readers understand the intended meaning behind your words.

Grammatical Rules for “Mine and His”

Even though phrases like “mine and his” are frequently encountered in everyday conversation, they do not conform to the established grammatical standards of the English language. The cause of this incorrect usage stems from the incorrect pronoun order, which is a fundamental aspect of possessive pronoun guidelines in English grammar.

To convey joint ownership accurately, it is crucial to adhere to the grammatical rules for possession. A basic principle that governs these rules is to position the first person possessive pronoun (in this case, “mine”) second in the compound possessive construction. Thus, the correct formation should be “his and mine.”

Incorrect: This car is mine and his.
Correct: This car is his and mine.

In the context of the example above, the corrected formation “his and mine” accurately represents the shared ownership of the car. By following this structure, the sentence complies with the established possessive pronoun guidelines, ensuring that the meaning is clear and grammatically valid.

  1. Incorrect: These are mine and his books.
  2. Correct: These are his and mine books.
  3. Incorrect: The responsibility is mine and his.
  4. Correct: The responsibility is his and mine.

By correcting the pronoun order, you not only enhance the clarity of your messages but also maintain grammatical correctness. Overall, when expressing shared possession, remember to place the first person possessive pronoun second in the phrase, such as “his and mine.”

Additional Incorrect Formations Like “Mine and His”

Just like the nonstandard possessive form “mine and his,” there are other common grammatical errors that involve pronoun order mistakes. These incorrect structures occur when the first-person possessive pronoun (mine) takes precedence improperly. A couple of such formations to avoid are “mine and hers” and “mine and Steve’s.”

Let’s explore these incorrect examples in more detail and observe the right way to use personal pronouns in each situation to maintain grammatical accuracy.

1. Mine and Hers:

Incorrect: “The room was decorated by mine and hers.”

Correct: “The room was decorated by hers and mine.”

2. Mine and Steve’s:

Incorrect: “This is mine and Steve’s project.”

Correct: “This is Steve’s and mine project.”

Now that we understand the errors, let’s check out a list of correct versions to learn how to rectify these common mistakes.

  1. Own the mistake and learn from it. Reflect on it and make an effort not to repeat it in the future.
  2. Practice using the correct forms. Write sentences with various possessive pronouns to gain a better understanding of the right structure.
  3. Ask for help! If you’re unsure about the usage of certain pronouns, consult a friend, colleague, or grammar resource for guidance.
  4. Read more! Being exposed to well-written content can help refine your grammatical prowess and enhance your understanding of the English language.

By making a conscious effort to avoid nonstandard possessive forms and recognizing common grammatical errors, you’ll be well on your way to enhancing your English language skills and communicating more effectively in both written and spoken forms.

Yours and His – Sharing Possession Correctly

Linking possessive pronouns correctly is essential for expressing shared possession and maintaining grammatical precision in your writing. The phrase “yours and his” accurately represents the collective ownership of two people sharing the possession of the same noun. When using pronouns such as “yours” before other possessives, you can convey ownership without confusion, ensuring shared possession clarity in your sentence.

How to Link Possessive Pronouns Appropriately

When forming proper possessive pairings, remember that the first-person possessive pronoun should come last in the list of pronouns. This ordering maintains grammatical integrity and helps prevent ambiguity. Here are some guidelines to follow:

  1. Place “yours” before other possessive pronouns.
  2. Ensure proper noun agreement with the pronouns used.
  3. Avoid placeholder pronouns and always use real possession indicators.

Examples to Demonstrate Proper Use of “Yours and His”

To better understand the correct application of linking possessive pronouns, examine the following proper pronoun usage examples:

Yours and his dog is no good to us.

This sentence showcases the proper pairing of “yours” and “his” along with the subject “dog.” It indicates that the dog is jointly owned by you and him.

That bag is yours and his.

By placing “yours” before “his,” the proper possessive pairing is once again preserved, clearly showing that the bag belongs to both parties.

Additionally, when swapping other pronouns or adding names, the same rule applies:

The child is yours and hers.

The sentence maintains grammatical correctness by placing “yours” before “hers,” indicating the child is shared by you and her.

Common Pitfalls: “Your and His” vs. “Yours and His”

English grammar can be tricky, especially when it comes to possessive pronouns. One common possessive mistake people make is using “your and his” instead of “yours and his.” While both phrases might be understood in casual conversation, they hold different meanings, and using them interchangeably in formal writing can lead to confusion.

The distinction between correct vs. incorrect pronouns is crucial for conveying the intended message and maintaining grammatical accuracy. Using “yours and his” correctly reflects the possessive case when two people share ownership, such as in the sentence, “It is yours and his idea.” In contrast, employing “your and his” in this context would be a pronoun possession pitfall and should be avoided in formal writing. To prevent common errors, ensure you are mindful of the correct order and usage of possessive pronouns.

In conclusion, it’s important to recognize the difference between “your and his” and “yours and his” when discussing shared possession. By taking the time to understand the proper placement and context of these pronouns, you can improve your writing, communicate more effectively, and sidestep potential confusion stemming from grammatical inaccuracies.