Is It Correct to Say “Those Ones”?

Marcus Froland

When it comes to perfecting your English grammar and ensuring correct usage of demonstrative pronouns, sometimes the smallest mistakes can lead to confusion. In particular, debates arise over whether phrases like “those ones” or “these ones” are considered grammatically correct. In this guide, we’ll provide clarity on the matter by exploring the foundations of grammar rules and the nuances of language precision.

Understanding the Debate Around “These Ones” and “Those Ones”

The English language debate over the grammatical validity of “these ones” and “those ones” is far from unanimous. Opinions on the correctness of these plural demonstratives are influenced by geographical and cultural factors, showcasing the various language nuances that exist in English-speaking regions.

While “these ones” is less favored, particularly in American English, there’s historical acceptance of both phrases to certain extents.

Usage of “these ones” and “those ones” might be shaped by regional preferences and the ever-evolving nature of language. Despite the lack of consensus, contemporary grammar rules tend to favor avoiding redundancy. As a result, using “these” and “those” without the additional “ones” is generally recommended for clear communication.

It is worth noting that the debate surrounding “these ones” and “those ones” has not reached a clear-cut conclusion. Some linguistic communities accept both phrases, while others reject them entirely. As language changes and adapts over time, so too do the prevailing opinions on what constitutes appropriate usage of certain terms.

Grammatical Foundations: Demonstrative Pronouns Simplified

In order to fully understand the debate around using “these ones” and “those ones,” it is crucial to first establish a solid understanding of how demonstrative pronouns work in English grammar, specifically the transformation from singular to plural forms. This will provide a clearer perspective on the redundancy factor and simplify our language.

The Transformation from Singular to Plural Demonstratives

Demonstrative pronouns are used to indicate specific items or things, either in relation to distance or to make distinctions among them. The singular forms, this and that, transform into plural forms, these and those, respectively, when referring to multiple items. The context of their usage usually provides sufficient clarity, as shown in the following examples:

  1. This apple is fresh, but that one is rotten.
  2. These apples are fresh, but those are rotten.

As you can see, the shift from singular to plural forms doesn’t require adding “ones” to make sense.

Why Adding “Ones” May Be Redundant

Including “ones” with “these” or “those” is often considered redundant because the notion of plurality is already contained within the demonstrative pronouns themselves. Native speakers of English typically perceive the inclusion of “ones” as awkward or improper, and thus, it’s advisable to omit it for conciseness and simplicity. Take a look at the comparison:

These shoes are comfortable, but those are too tight.

These ones are comfortable, but those ones are too tight.

The first sentence conveys the intended message more efficiently and clearly, without the need for an extra word. Nevertheless, through familiarizing yourself with these grammatical foundations and focusing on language efficiency, you can navigate the nuances of English grammar and enhance your communication skills in various contexts.

The Argument Against “These Ones” in American English

In American English grammar, the phrase “these ones” is often viewed as a non-standard dialect. As opposed to “those ones,” it is considered less acceptable in formal settings. While there is no concrete rule prohibiting its use, language experts and linguists generally recommend avoiding “these ones” in formal contexts.

This argument is based on the belief that using standard language practices and maintaining grammatical correctness is essential for clear communication. Since many Americans find “these ones” jarring or improper, using it might not efficiently convey the intended meaning.

For the sake of standard language practice and as a result of its jarring effect on many, avoiding ‘these ones’ in formal contexts is recommended.

Given the importance of the language arguments, it is crucial to familiarize yourself with the norms and conventions of the American English grammar. By doing so, you will be better equipped to navigate the complexities of the language and communicate effectively in different settings.

As you work on improving your American English grammar skills, consider the following recommendations:

  • Avoid using “these ones” in formal settings, such as academic essays or professional emails.
  • Opt for “these” without the added “ones” for conciseness.
  • Be attentive to regional variation and adjust your language accordingly when necessary.

Although “these ones” does not have a concrete rule prohibiting its use, it is best to steer clear of it in formal contexts to maintain grammatical correctness and adhere to standard American English practices.

“Those Ones” vs. “These Ones”: A Historical Perspective

Delving into the historical usage of English language and linguistic insights, it becomes evident that the phrases “those ones” and “these ones” have appeared in literature throughout the centuries, challenging the current perceptions of their correctness.

A thorough exploration of historical language usage and early literature review can help us better understand the development of the English language and the evolution of its grammar rules.

Tracing the Usage of “Those Ones” Through Centuries

“Those ones” can be traced back to writings from as early as the 1600s, where it appeared in varied content types such as comedies, economic analyses, and political histories. These instances signify its use and acceptance in both formal and informal contexts over the centuries. Some examples from the 1600s include the works of playwright William Congreve and political writer Samuel Purchas, proving that “those ones” held a place in English language development.

Insights into “These Ones” from Early Literature

Similarly, “these ones” appeared in written records since the 1700s, with instances found in theological texts, magazine stories, and other early literature. The writings of theologian John Wesley and essayist Richard Steele provide historical evidence of “these ones” being used in the past. The presence of “these ones” in these works challenges current perceptions of the phrase as informal or non-standard, shedding light on its roots in linguistics history.

  1. Historical language usage of “those ones” and “these ones” can be traced back centuries, suggesting a consistent presence in written work.
  2. Early literature review reveals instances of these phrases in various content types, proving they held a place in language evolution.
  3. Linguistic insights from the past challenge current perceptions of their correctness, inspiring a reevaluation of their status in modern English.

While current grammar rules lean more heavily towards avoiding the use of “those ones” or “these ones,” their presence in historical English literature cannot be ignored. As language continues to evolve, it’s crucial to consider linguistic history and the nuances of English language development in our communication.

Regional Varieties and Preferences in English Usage

One of the most intriguing aspects of the English language is the significant variation in grammatical structures and vocabulary across different regions. Such language preferences and dialectal differences shape debates about grammatical correctness, including whether ‘these ones’ and ‘those ones’ are appropriate to use.

In British English, the use of ‘these ones’ might be more commonly accepted, as it often aligns closely with regional vernacular speech patterns. By contrast, in North American English, the use of ‘these ones’ may be more restricted and subject to local linguistic norms. In some communities, it may be perceived as less formal, whereas others might not regard it as unusual at all.

English usage varies significantly by region, including the use of ‘these ones’ and ‘those ones’. This diversity highlights the complex, evolving nature of the language across various geographies.

It is essential to consider regional differences when engaging in conversations or composing written works for global audiences. While some expressions or phrases may be widely understood and accepted in one region, they might not be recognized or appreciated elsewhere. Keeping regional English variations, language preferences, and dialectal differences in mind can help you craft clear, effective communication that resonates with diverse audiences.

  1. Be aware of regional variations and preferences in English usage.
  2. Consider the intended audience when choosing vocabulary and expressions.
  3. Use standard English in formal settings to ensure clarity and avoid confusion.
  4. Embrace the fluidity and evolution of language, adapting your communication style as needed.

Ultimately, understanding and respecting regional variations in English usage can enrich your communication. As long as you maintain clarity and adhere to established grammatical rules, your message will undoubtedly resonate with your intended audience.

When Might “These Ones” or “Those Ones” Be Acceptable?

While the debate surrounding the grammatical correctness of using “these ones” or “those ones” continues, there may be certain situations where these phrases could potentially work, depending on the intended meaning. It’s essential to understand the nuances of when to use them while acknowledging the general preference for avoiding them in formal communication.

Consider instances where a clear distinction between items is necessary, and the traditional usage of “these” or “those” without the additional “ones” might not fully convey the intended meaning. For example:

“I prefer these red ones to the green ones.”

In this case, “these” operates as an adjective, specifying a particular group of items, while “ones” signifies the noun. The phrase emphasizes the distinction between the objects in question and could be useful for guiding the listener’s comprehension and facilitating more communicative effectiveness.

However, remember that employing “these ones” or “those ones” might be acceptable in certain conversational settings, but not in formal writing or speaking situations. Adhering to recognized grammar rules is crucial for avoiding errors and maintaining language flexibility while ensuring your message is conveyed precisely as intended.

  • Do utilize “these ones” or “those ones” when the situation calls for a clear distinction between items and the traditional use of “these” or “those” on their own doesn’t serve the intended purpose.
  • Don’t use “these ones” or “those ones” in formal writing or in circumstances where you want to maintain strict adherence to standard grammar rules.

While there may be some unique cases where “these ones” or “those ones” can be acceptable, it’s generally advised to stick to the more concise and universally accepted alternatives. Understanding the intricacies of demonstrative pronouns is key to maintaining language accuracy and acceptable grammar usage in the English language. Remember to be mindful of the context in which you employ these phrases and proceed cautiously.

Enhancing Language Precision: Tips for Clear English Grammar

As a speaker of English, you might be wondering how to improve your language precision and maintain established grammar rules. One way to ensure clarity and accuracy in your communication is by avoiding unnecessary phrases like “these ones” and “those ones.” By sticking to “these” and “those” without adding “ones,” you’ll achieve a higher level of linguistic excellence and be better understood in both formal and informal contexts.

There are instances when you might need to use additional qualifiers, such as when you want to emphasize a specific meaning or distinction between different groups of items. In these cases, carefully consider how to convey your message without creating redundancy or confusion. Remember to always prioritize effective communication, and you’ll be well on your way to mastering the nuances of English grammar.

By applying these English grammar tips and focusing on language precision, you can craft compelling and accurate messages that resonate with your intended audience. Keep refining your skills, learn from your mistakes, and practice often. As you evolve and grow as a communicator, you’ll be able to confidently navigate the complexities of the English language while making a lasting impact on your readers.